Decision trace

23 Sept · decided in about 2 days. Nothing was released. Each step is signed or on chain.

1. Stephen John sent the work

   On chain as bafkreia…q3ai.

   0 s

2. asks.world reviewer gathered the facts

   Measured the light, the distance, recent payouts nearby, the order of the photographs, where the photograph was taken and the photograph's generator marks, and checked for duplicates. Three AI reviews by openai/gpt-5.6-luna scored 98, 94 and 98 out of 100. The facts were frozen before deciding. The reviewer's record

   48 h

3. IXO decision engine did not approve it

   Of 12 rules, 8 met, 1 not met and 3 not reached.

   • Handed over: met
   • Not AI-generated: met
   • Not AI-generated: met
   • Taken there: met
   • Taken there: met
   • In the area: met
   • Before, then after: met
   • Daylight fits: not reached
   • Not paid here recently: not reached
   • Judged by AI: met
   • Judged by AI: not met
   • Judged by AI: not reached

   • The two photographs are of the same place. Waste has been taken away between them, so look at the ground, the walls, the kerb and whatever else stands still. Fail this only if they are plainly two different places.

   Every rule in full

   • Something was handed over: metmeasured
   • Nothing in the photograph says an AI generator made it: metmeasured
   • Nothing in the photograph says an AI generator made it: metmeasured
   • Every photograph is a direct photograph of a real place, and the ground being cleared is outdoors in a street, verge, park, beach, watercourse, lot or other public or shared outdoor space.: metAI review
   • Taken at the place reported: metmeasured
   • Taken at the place reported: metmeasured
   • Within the distance the ask set: metmeasured
   • The two photographs are of the same place, in order: metmeasured
   • The two photographs are of the same place. Waste has been taken away between them, so look at the ground, the walls, the kerb and whatever else stands still. Fail this only if they are plainly two different places.: not metAI review
   • The after photograph shows less litter on the ground than the before photograph. Fail this if as much waste is still lying there, or more.: not reachedAI review
   • The light fits the place and the time: not reachedmeasured
   • Nowhere this close was paid for recently: not reachedmeasured
   48 h

4. Signed by the decision engine

   decision-engine.ixo.earth. The signature checks out against its published key. Check it

   48 h

5. Recorded on chain: not approved

   Nothing was released.

   48 h

Full engine trace pinned by hash 1a5cb212…